Why Monarchy? The Rise and Demise of a Regime Type

Abstract

Monarchy was the dominant form of rule in the pre-modern era and it persists in a handful of countries. We propose a unified theoretical explanation for its rise and decline. Specifically, we argue that monarchy offers an efficient solution to the primordial problem of order where societies are large and citizens isolated from each other and hence have difficulty coordinating. Its efficiency is challenged by other methods of leadership selection when communication costs decline, lowering barriers to citizen coordination. This explains its dominance in the pre-modern world and its subsequent demise. To test this theory, we produce an original dataset that codes monarchies and republics in Europe (back to 1100) and the world (back to 1700). With this dataset, we test a number of observable implications of the theory – centering on territory size, political stability, tenure in office, conflict, and the role of mass communications in the modern era.

Publication
Forthcoming at Comparative Political Studies

Monarchies in Europe

Monarchies in the world